I (22F) have an older sister (28F) who has four kids. She loves being a mom and dreams of being a stay-at-home mom, which I fully support. However, she understands that I have no desire to be a mom right now—if ever. I also have two other older sisters who, like me, don’t want to be stay-at-home mothers. This context is important for the story.
My sister’s boyfriend (27M) recently got upset with me. It started when he asked when I planned to “settle down” and even offered to introduce me to a friend of his (25M) who is looking for a stay-at-home wife. I told him no, explaining that I’m not interested in dating anyone this year. He got annoyed and pressed me for a reason, so I told him about my trust issues stemming from an ex who cheated on me for six months during our three-year relationship.
He brushed it off, saying the breakup was in 2023 and I should “move on” already. I told him it wasn’t his business, and he dropped it—for a while.
Two days later, he asked if I’d ever consider being a stay-at-home wife and mom. I told him no, explaining that I’m not even sure if I want kids, let alone to get married. This seemed to upset him since his mother was a stay-at-home wife and mom. I made it clear that while I respect those who choose that path, it’s not for me. I told him I don’t want to depend on a man for anything. He got defensive, saying “not all men are the same,” and I agreed, but reminded him that “not all women want the same things either.”
He pointed out that my sister wants to be a stay-at-home wife and mom, and I congratulated him on finding that with her. But I reiterated that I don’t want the same.
Things escalated when he overheard me talking about getting an IUD. He told me I was “ruining God’s plan” for me to be a mother. I told him that whether or not I want kids is none of his business. He got mad and told me to leave his house, so I did.
Now my sister is asking me to apologize to him and reconsider getting the IUD, saying that if I were to get pregnant, it would be “God’s plan.” She also accused me of not respecting stay-at-home mothers, which is completely untrue.
My two other sisters are on my side, saying that my sister’s boyfriend has no right to concern himself with how I live my life. They support my decision to remain independent and not depend on anyone if that’s what I choose.
To top it off, he told me I’m “going to hell” for being bisexual, so I snapped and yelled that if that’s the case, then my sister (his girlfriend) is going to hell too since she’s also bisexual—which he already knows. Now, their friends are calling me an asshole, saying he only cares because “it’s God’s body” and I should “respect it” by becoming a mom.
So, AITA for telling my sister’s boyfriend to mind his own business about my decision not to be a stay-at-home wife or mom?
TL;DR: My sister’s boyfriend is upset that I don’t want to depend on a man or be a stay-at-home mom, and he’s also mad about my decision to get an IUD, claiming I’m ruining “God’s plan.” I told him to mind his own business, and now I’m being called an asshole.
Edit for clarification: Three out of my sister’s four kids aren’t even his. She has a 7-year-old, a 4-year-old, a 3-year-old, and is currently expecting a newborn.