First, I want to thank everyone who read my original post, offered advice, or helped me feel less alone in this situation. I had planned to reply to comments and answer questions, but things escalated so quickly that I’ve been too stressed to even process it all. Now, I have new information that has completely changed everything.
My brother, Alex, is currently staying with my wife, Jess, and me. He showed up unexpectedly late last night, and after a long talk, he shared the full story of what happened between him and Hannah, his wife, after the Christmas party.
Alex told me he took some time and space to think before sitting down with Hannah for a serious talk. During that time, he realized she had lied to him, and I had been telling the truth. Still, he wanted to give her a chance to explain herself—why she lied, why she treated me the way she did, and how she justified all of it.
When confronted, Hannah first tried to deflect and gaslight him. But when Alex held firm, she snapped. She admitted she had always disliked me and blamed it on being uncomfortable with “my lifestyle.” She also confessed that Jess makes her particularly uncomfortable due to her masculine-presenting appearance and clothing. She said she was tired of pretending none of this upset her. Alex shared some of her comments but spared me the worst.
This admission led to the real reason for her lies. Hannah confessed that she intentionally brought her baby to my wedding and hoped the baby’s crying would disrupt the ceremony, making me seem unreasonable. At the Christmas party, she planned to create another scene to make me look like the aggressor while painting herself as a victim to the family. Her goal was to discredit me entirely.
While I always sensed she disliked me, I never realized her feelings were rooted in such blatant homophobia. Knowing this now, I’m relieved I called out her behavior at the party. I’ll never feel guilty for standing up to someone’s hate again.
But Alex wasn’t done. He told me Hannah made even more shocking confessions. After her homophobic rant, she began pacing nervously before dropping another bombshell. Not only has she been having an affair, but she’s also certain Alex isn’t the biological father of the child they’ve been raising together for the past 11 months.
If that wasn’t bad enough, she revealed the affair has been ongoing for six years—essentially the entire duration of their marriage. She claimed it was “love at first sight” when she met her college friend’s older brother, Josh (42M), at a party six years ago. Yet, she still married Alex because she believed he was “her perfect match.” None of it makes sense.
Hannah has since moved on overnight with Josh and their baby, leaving Alex utterly devastated. He’s staying with us for now, as things with Hannah are tense and hostile. Divorce is inevitable, but with Christmas around the corner, Alex has decided to put everything “on pause” for the moment. I respect his decision, but I can’t wait for her to officially be out of our lives.
It’s heartbreaking to see my brother betrayed like this, and I’m deeply hurt by the hatred Hannah harbored towards me just because of my sexuality. For now, I’m focusing on supporting Alex and spending time with Jess.
I don’t know if I’ll have another update, but this whole ordeal has left me completely drained.